Skip to main content

McCarren Hotel Reviews

Reviews of Hotels in Brooklyn NYC

Enough talking about ourselves already. We can tell you all day why we think we’re one of the best and most unique hotels in not just Brooklyn but all of NYC, but we think it’s better if you hear from our guests. If you’re considering a stay at McCarren Hotel & Pool, we invite you to experience us through the eyes of your fellow urban nomads by checking out the hotel reviews below.  

Hotel was great and especially Martin who was there anytime we needed anything. Martin also had some great recommendations for food in the neighborhood. We enjoyed the pool view from our room and the complimentary breakfast that we enjoyed poolside.

Mary B B

"Wonderful. Will keep booking for work travel."Great location. I'm from Brooklyn, and this is a very nice neighborhood to stay in. Close to L train and G train. Near bars/restaurants but not too close that it is loud on the street of the hotel. It was all good. Wish pool was open still as it was a hot day, but closed for season. Also, wish rooftop was open, would have been nice to sit up there.


The staff really very nice and caring. The location in Brooklyn, not far from a direct subway line to Manathan. Rooms with balcony really nice. Too bad to be called hotel & pool, when the pool is closed even by 31 degrees. As well as the roof top. While the hotel only communicates on these two points. So if you go after September 30 it's just a hotel without other services


The staff are absolutely amazing - friendly and professional. Nothing is too much and they are happy to chat and give advice unlike some NY hotels. Best service I’ve had in New York yet. I will definitely be back.


Although the room was small, it had all of the accommodations of a larger chain hotel. It was a comfortable stay. I also liked the fact that I had a room with a view of the pool. The room was smaller than I expected, but it was comfortable. Also, there was no bathtub in my room. (But then again, I don't know if any of the rooms had bathtubs.)


Amazing hotel with fantastic front desk staff - Fantastic staff especially the front desk we'd had a bad experience with an accommodation somewhere else and we turned up very later and they couldn't do enough for us. The room was huge and we loved the pool. A great stay. We loved everything

Gillian Albutt